Buyer & Seller Advice
A low appraisal can be unexpected and stressful. Here’s what it means, how it affects your financing, and what your options are when buying a home in Massachusetts.
What happens if a Massachusetts home doesn’t appraise for the purchase price?
A low appraisal does not automatically cancel the sale or require the seller to lower the price.
Instead, it can create a financing problem because mortgage lenders generally use the property’s appraised value when determining how much they are willing to lend. What happens next depends on the buyer’s financing, the appraisal itself, the purchase contract, and whether the parties are willing to renegotiate.
For buyers, the most important question is not simply whether the appraisal came in low. It is:
You can ask the seller to reduce the price to—or toward—the appraised value.
You may choose to cover some or all of the difference if your lender allows it and you have the funds.
Ask your lender about a Reconsideration of Value (ROV) if you find errors.
Whether you can cancel depends on your offer, P&S, and contingency deadlines.
A home appraisal is an independent professional opinion of a property’s value. The appraiser reviews information about the property and market, which may include:
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes an appraisal as a written opinion of how much a property is worth. Massachusetts’ appraiser consumer fact sheet notes that the lender needs an accurate estimate of value.
No. An appraisal and a home inspection serve different purposes.
A home inspection is primarily intended to help the buyer understand the property’s physical condition. An appraisal is primarily concerned with determining or supporting the property’s value for the lender.
An appraiser may observe characteristics or conditions that affect value, but an appraisal should not be treated as a substitute for a home inspection. Buyers may need both during the same transaction.
When an appraisal is being used for a mortgage loan, the lender generally controls the appraisal process.
Massachusetts consumer guidance notes that federal and state laws usually require the lender to hire the appraiser when the appraisal will be used for a real estate loan. That helps preserve the appraiser’s independence.
The buyer normally pays the appraisal cost through the mortgage process, although the exact arrangement depends on the lender and transaction.
Not necessarily. A cash buyer may decide whether to obtain an independent appraisal.
For financed purchases, a lender may require an appraisal or may use another valuation method. The CFPB notes that lenders can use other methods to check a home’s value. Buyers should ask their lender what type of valuation will be required for their particular loan.
A home “doesn’t appraise” when the appraised value is lower than the agreed purchase price. For example:
The difference is often informally called an appraisal gap. But that does not necessarily mean the buyer automatically has to bring exactly $25,000 more to closing.
The actual financing impact depends on the buyer’s loan amount, down payment, loan program, lender requirements, and other underwriting factors.
Mortgage lenders evaluate the relationship between the loan amount and the property’s value.
For standard Fannie Mae purchase-money mortgages, the loan-to-value calculation uses the lower of the sales price or the current appraised value. Freddie Mac uses the same general approach for standard purchase transactions.
That means a lower appraisal can reduce the value the lender uses to calculate the mortgage. The lender may therefore:
The exact impact should be confirmed with the buyer’s lender.
No. A low appraisal does not automatically require the seller to reduce the agreed purchase price. The seller may decide to:
The CFPB notes that buyers can often use the lower appraised value to negotiate a reduction in the sales price. But negotiation requires agreement from both sides.
Potentially. A buyer may decide to contribute additional cash if the lender will still approve the loan and the buyer has sufficient funds. But buyers should discuss this with their lender before assuming how much additional money will be required. The amount needed may depend on:
A low appraisal does not always translate dollar-for-dollar into the amount of additional cash required.
Yes—the buyer can ask. A lower appraisal may give the buyer and seller a reason to reopen the conversation about price. Possible negotiated solutions may include:
Whether a seller agrees depends on the property, market conditions, competing demand, financing, and the parties’ willingness to compromise.
Maybe. This is where the purchase contract becomes extremely important.
Massachusetts does not create one automatic statewide rule allowing every buyer to cancel simply because the property appraises below the purchase price. Massachusetts Purchase and Sale guidance explains that buyers and sellers may negotiate contingencies, including financing. The CFPB likewise notes that a buyer may want to cancel if the seller won’t lower the price, but recommends checking the contract and consulting an attorney because cancelling may carry costs.
A buyer’s ability to terminate may therefore depend on:
Massachusetts advises buyers to consult an attorney regarding contracts.
Not necessarily. These provisions can overlap, but they should not automatically be treated as identical.
A mortgage or financing contingency generally addresses the buyer’s ability to obtain the financing described in the contract. An appraisal contingency or appraisal-gap provision, when included, may address what happens specifically if the property’s appraised value is below the agreed price.
The exact legal effect depends on the language used. Buyers should not assume a mortgage contingency automatically provides unlimited protection from every low-appraisal scenario. The buyer’s attorney should review the actual contract.
An appraisal-gap clause is a negotiated contract provision addressing how much, if anything, a buyer is willing to pay above the appraised value. For example, a buyer might agree—depending on the actual wording—to cover a specified amount of a valuation shortfall.
These clauses can be used in competitive markets to strengthen an offer, but they can also increase the buyer’s financial exposure. A buyer considering an appraisal-gap provision should understand:
This language should be reviewed carefully before the offer is signed.
Potentially, yes. If the buyer believes an appraisal contains errors, uses inappropriate comparable sales, omits relevant information, or is otherwise unsupported, the buyer may be able to request a Reconsideration of Value, commonly called an ROV, through the lender.
Fannie Mae has borrower-initiated ROV requirements, and for loans sold to Fannie Mae, the lender is responsible for ensuring compliance with them.
Start by reviewing the appraisal itself. Look for potential issues such as:
A buyer’s Realtor may be able to help identify relevant comparable sales or property information that can be provided to the lender.
No. An ROV is a request for the appraisal to be reviewed—not a guarantee that the value will change. The appraiser may:
For Fannie Mae loans, the lender decides whether to accept the appraiser’s conclusions and must work with the appraiser to correct material deficiencies.
Not automatically. A buyer can raise concerns with the lender and ask what options are available, but the lender generally determines whether another appraisal is appropriate or usable for the mortgage. Fannie Mae’s ROV guidance notes that when an ROV concludes with no change in value, a new appraisal is not available through that process.
A buyer may also choose to obtain an independent appraisal for personal use, although that appraisal may not automatically replace the lender’s valuation.
For a typical first-mortgage home loan, yes. The CFPB states that borrowers are generally entitled to free copies of appraisals and other written valuations, delivered promptly after the lender receives them and no later than three days before closing.
Buyers should actually read it rather than looking only at the final value. The report may contain important information about:
Generally, that is easier for the financing side of the transaction. If the appraised value meets or exceeds the purchase price, the valuation itself does not create an appraisal-gap problem.
However, a higher appraisal does not automatically change the purchase price. If the buyer agreed to pay $650,000 and the property appraises for more, the buyer does not normally receive an automatic price reduction. The contract price remains the contract price unless the parties agree otherwise.
A cash buyer is not dealing with a lender’s mortgage-value requirements, so a low appraisal may not create the same financing problem. However, a cash buyer may still care greatly about whether the agreed purchase price is supported by market value. Whether a cash buyer can renegotiate or terminate because of a valuation issue still depends on the contract.
Potentially. A low appraisal alone does not automatically determine what happens to the buyer’s deposit. The outcome depends on the buyer’s contractual rights.
If the buyer properly terminates under an applicable contingency, the agreement may provide for return of the deposit. If the buyer has waived relevant protections, agreed to cover an appraisal gap, misses a deadline, or otherwise defaults, the result could be different. The offer and P&S should be reviewed carefully with the buyer’s attorney.
A buyer facing a low appraisal should generally work through the issue in this order:
The best option will vary from one transaction to another.
Sellers also have decisions to make. A seller may want to consider:
A low appraisal does not automatically prove the agreed price was wrong, but it can create a practical obstacle when the buyer needs mortgage financing.
No one can guarantee an appraisal result. But before offering significantly above recent comparable sales, buyers should understand the risk. Useful questions include:
Those questions are especially important when multiple offers push a sale price substantially above nearby recent sales.
No. The appraisal does not automatically rewrite the purchase contract. The buyer and seller must agree to any change in price.
Possibly. The answer depends on the offer, P&S, financing contingency, appraisal language, and whether the buyer follows the applicable deadlines.
Not automatically. An appraisal is a professional opinion of value based on available market evidence. Different valuations can sometimes produce different results. The report should be reviewed to understand how the appraiser reached the conclusion.
No. The appraiser’s independence must be respected. Concerns about an appraisal should generally be submitted through the lender’s approved review or reconsideration process.
Potentially, yes. The buyer should first ask the lender exactly how the lower appraisal affects the mortgage and closing funds.
They may negotiate a solution if both sides agree. The specific agreement should be documented properly.
No. A second appraisal may not be available, and even when another valuation is obtained, the lender decides which valuation can be relied upon under its underwriting requirements.
No. Contract protections are negotiated. Never assume a particular appraisal protection exists unless it is actually included in the signed documents.
It also does not automatically require the seller to reduce the price or guarantee that the buyer can cancel without consequences. Instead, a low appraisal creates a decision point. The buyer may need to:
For financed purchases, the lender’s valuation matters because major conventional mortgage programs generally calculate loan-to-value using the lower of the purchase price or appraised value.
For buyers, the best protection comes before the appraisal is ever ordered:
If you’re preparing to make an offer—or navigating an appraisal issue after your offer has been accepted—Nancy can help you understand the real estate side of the process and coordinate with your lender and attorney so you know what questions to ask next.
Search available properties at www.newhomema.com or contact Nancy at 508.954.3420.
Nancy Cassano | Realtor | Serving Greater Boston & Cape Cod
Phone: 508.954.3420
Email: nancyc@todayrealestate.com
Website: www.newhomema.com
This article reflects guidance reviewed in October 2026 and is intended for general real estate information only. Appraisal requirements, financing, contingencies, deposit rights, and cancellation rights depend on the particular loan and contract. Buyers and sellers should consult their lender and Massachusetts real estate attorney regarding their specific transaction.
Primary sources reviewed include the Massachusetts homebuying guide, Massachusetts Purchase and Sale Agreement training materials, the Massachusetts Real Estate Appraisers Consumer Fact Sheet, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau appraisal guidance, and current Fannie Mae valuation requirements.
Compare listings
Compare